You Can Trust

With more Insurance Company choices, we can help find you better rates. That’s the Crotty Insurance Difference!

Talk to Us

Beige-colored, one-story house with a Crotty Insurance Inc signage next to it

Your Trucking and Commercial Insurance Specialists

Protecting Truckers, Contractors and Other Businesses for the long haul.

Commercial Insurance

Two men walking in front of a fleet of shiny blue trucks

Personal Insurance Options to Fit Every Budget

Get the peace of mind you deserve with our affordable Home and Auto Insurance options.

Personal Insurance

Yes or no checklist about being insured

Access Us While
on the Go

Contact us from anywhere at anytime by using your mobile device and one of our friendly team members will be happy to assist you!

Talk to Us

Two cellphones and a tablet placed on top of an open laptop

Industry-Best Trucking Insurance

The Name You Can Trust

As an independent insurance agency, we are here to represent your interests, not the interests of any particular insurance company. As a result, we can offer you customization, freedom of choice, and a level of consultation you won’t find with a direct writer or online insurance provider.

Crotty Insurance Inc
Crotty Insurance Inc

Friendly Personalized Service

We understand that insurance is unlike most other products you spend your hard-earned money on. It’s something that you pay for and hopes you never have to use. And when you spend more than you need to, that makes everything that much more frustrating. That’s why Crotty Insurance has a team of friendly experts to tailor your policy to meet your exact needs and budget.

Trucking Insurance Specialists

At Crotty Insurance, we understand the trucking business and the unique needs of owner-operators. With seasoned insurance brokers and staff with over 60 years of combined insurance experience, you can trust Crotty Insurance to meet your commercial trucking insurance needs.

Crotty Insurance Inc

Find out why everyone is talking
about Crotty Insurance

About Crotty Insurance

An Insurance Partner You Can Trust!

Crotty Insurance Agency, Inc. has been providing exceptional, affordable insurance to residents and businesses in Pennsylvania, New York, and Ohio for over 29 years. We are an independent insurance agency representing many of the top insurers in the county including Travelers, Ohio Casualty, Penn National, Encompass, and Progressive just to name a few. Our professionals will tailor-make a program to fit your specific needs, whether for your personal insurance or for your business. We are a family-run business with a caring, personal touch. At Crotty Insurance, you’re not just a customer, you’re family. Let us be your one-stop-shop for all your insurance needs!

Crotty Insurance Inc

Personal Insurance Lines

Enhanced Personal Insurance Protection for Individuals and Families. For your car, motorcycle, boat, home, or rental property

As a client of Crotty Insurance, you won’t have to spend time researching and comparing all your insurance options. We’ll do the work for you! As an independent insurance agency, we represent many of the country’s finest insurance companies and can recommend the right insurance to fit your needs at the most competitive price. We offer you exceptional value and comprehensive coverage.

We believe that the more our clients know about their personal insurance options, the better equipped they are to make good insurance decisions. That’s why we’ve provided some in-depth explanations of our broad portfolio of protection programs. However, we understand that each person’s circumstances are different, so please feel free to contact us or drop by one of our offices for more information. We’re happy to take the time to discuss each item in detail with you.

Crotty Insurance Inc

Commercial Insurance Lines

Enhanced Insurance Protection for Businesses in Pennsylvania, New York, and Ohio

As our client, the success of your business is our top priority. We’ll work with you as a partner to ensure your business risk is effectively managed and where possible, reduced, in order to minimize your costs both now and in the future. Our unique approach offers you superior business protection and delivers unparalleled results.

In addition to receiving a customized business insurance program, you’ll also receive:

  • Comprehensive risk management
  • Cost containment and reduction strategies
  • Loss control analysis and advice
  • Frequent policy audits and coverage reviews
Crotty Insurance Inc
Crotty Insurance Inc

I was complaining about my car insurance to a friend of mine at work and she told me that she had been using Crotty Insurance for a couple of years and was really happy. I talked to my husband about it and we decided to give them a call. After we met Denny and went over all of our options we decided to make the switch. We were a little nervous because we’d been with our previous agent for a long time. I am writing this review several months after having switched (have to wait and see, right?) and I can honestly say that I wish we’d have switched sooner! It’s definitely one of the better decisions we’ve made.

I Switched on Advice from a Co-Worker